Why do people say yes but do no?
It is a common frustration among change agents: people who say yes but do no.
Why do they do that?
That is a difficult question to answer. After all, there are countless reasons why people do what they do. Or do not do. And often we do not even know ourselves why we do what we do, let alone that we can pinpoint it in others.
Still, I dare to offer some guidance. It lies in your assessment of how people relate to the change you want them to say yes to.
I see six possibilities.

1. They did not say yes
Then you interpreted their silence as agreement. It is high time we bury the saying ‘silence gives consent’ in the graveyard of destructive beliefs (next to ‘those who ask are skipped’). People who are silent do not say yes, and therefore they do no.
2. They said yes in denial
Then they said yes, but to something other than what you think they said yes to. For example, because the conversation got stuck in an abstract idea that ‘we’ should do something with. And therefore they do no.
3. They said yes in resistance
Then they said yes to something they do not want, because at that moment they did not feel the space to say so. They do not want to be difficult or are worried you will use it against them. Their yes is on the handbrake. The result is avoidance and procrastination. And therefore they do no.
4. They said yes in euphoria
Then they enthusiastically shouted yes and eagerly got to work. Then came the inevitable reality check. The change also had disadvantages and they found they were losing something too. Now they are, back from the cold fair, gathering courage to tell you they would rather not go through with it. And therefore they do no.
5. They said yes in reflection
Then the change struck a chord with them and they are searching for their role. They want to do yes, but still feel uncertain, have questions and need help and guidance. The hitch arises when there is no one to help them. Their reflection fades. And therefore they do no.
6. They said yes in connection
Then they understand what they said yes to and feel responsible for it. They are committed. The only reason they have not done yes yet is that the situation where it is needed has not yet occurred. And therefore they do no for now.
So?
Do not count your chickens too soon when people say yes. Pay particular attention to how they say yes.
In all six causes, it is misplaced or too early to expect the other to do yes. The key lies with you to encourage the other to come out of denial, acknowledge their resistance, let their euphoria settle, nurture their reflection and capitalise on their connection.
When people say yes, the conversation is not over. It has only just begun.
Annemarie Mars, March 2023
A contribution of
From reading to listening?
The best stories truly come to life on stage. Our consultants will be happy to advise you personally.